2005 SUBARU OUTBACK Complaints

RIGHT AND LEFT FRONT CONTROL ARM BUSHINGS SPLIT AND REPLACED ALONG WITH BOTH FRONT CONTROL ARMS. *TR

BOUGHT THE CAR FROM A TOYOTA DEALER IN JUNE 2011. WITHIN 5 DAYS OF BUYING IT, WHEN DRIVING THE CAR ON HIGHWAY, WITHIN 15 MINS OF DRIVING, ALL OF A SUDDEN THE CAR JERKS, WITH A SUDDEN DROP IN SPEED, WITH THE CHECK ENGINE LIGHT TURNED ON AND CRUISE LIGHT STARTING TO BLINK. CAR WOULD NOT SPEED UP NO MATTER HOW MUCH THE ACCELERATOR IS PRESSED. I HAD TO PULL THE CAR TO THE SIDE OF THE ROAD. I HAVE TAKEN IT SEVERAL TIMES TO SUBARU SERVICE...THEY SEEM TO KNOW WHAT THE PROBLEM IS AND ATTEMPT TO FIX IT - I PAY THEM AND DRIVE IT BACK HOME AND, THE SAME PROBLEM PERSISTS. I GET THE SAME CODE EACH TIME - P0638. REPLACED THROTTLE BODY. REPLACED TIMING BELT. REPLACED THE THROTTLE CONTROL RELAY. ETC. THE MECHANICS SEEM TO TEST DRIVE IT AND FIND NO PROBLEM WITH IT. EVERY TIME THEY SEEM CONFIDENT THAT THEY HAVE FIXED IT. BUT, EVERYTIME I BEGIN TO DRIVE, THE CAR FAULTS AND THE SPEED DROPS IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ROAD. IT IS A DANGER TO ANYONE IN THE CAR AND TO PASSENGERS IN OTHER CARS. *TR

PURCHASED 2005 OUTBACK IN APRIL 2012 WITH APPROXIMATELY 190000 MILES. CAR FELT VERY UNSTABLE WHEN GOING OVER ANY UNEVEN ROAD SURFACE. REPLACED REAR STRUTS WITH NO IMPROVEMENT. TRIED DIFFERENT TIRES WITH NO NOTICEABLE CHANGE. DECIDED IT MUST BE AN ODD BUT NORMAL CONDITION FOR THE VEHICLE. TODAY, 9/18/12, DROVE CAR IN LIGHT RAIN ALONG A 2-LANE ROAD AT APPROXIMATELY 50-55 MPH AND CAR WAS VERY UNSTABLE IN THE REAR. THE REAR "STEERED" LEFT/RIGHT AND FELT VERY UNSTABLE. THERE WAS A SENSE THE VEHICLE WAS GOING TO ABRUPTLY CROSS INTO THE OTHER LANE. I HAVE OVER 40 YEARS OF DRIVING EXPERIENCE AND REALIZE THIS IS NOT NORMAL VEHICLE PERFORMANCE. I LIVE IN A CENTRAL NY AND PURCHASED THIS VEHICLE FOR THE SAFETY OF ALL WHEEL DRIVE AFTER OWNING A 1995 SUBARU IMPREZA AND A 1997 SUBARU OUTBACK. GIVEN THE SITUATION I HAD TODAY, I AM AFRAID OF WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN ICE/SNOW CONDITIONS COMMON IN NY. I BEGAN TO RESEARCH THE ISSUE ONLINE IN AN ATTEMPT TO CORRECT MY SITUATION BEFORE WINTER ARRIVES. I FOUND MANY ONLINE CONCERNS REGARDING THIS ISSUE. WHILE I HAVE NOT YET APPROACHED SUBARU DIRECTLY, I GET AN OVERWHELMING SENSE FROM ONLINE COMMENTS THAT SUBARU WILL NOT BE VERY HELPFUL. I AM MAKING THIS SAFETY COMPLAINT IN HOPES THAT MULTIPLE COMPLAINTS COMBINED WILL EXPOSE WHAT I FEEL IS A VERY SERIOUS/DANGEROUS HANDLING ISSUE WITH A 2005 SUBARU OUTBACK. *TR

2005 SUBARU IS OUR FAMILY HAS HAD TO HAVE THE FRONT AXLES AS ONE BROKE GOING DOWN THE HIGHWAY HE AS NOT HURT, BUT THE CAR WAS ONLY STOPPED AFTER I PLOWED UP SN OPEN FIELD. SINCE VEHICLE WAS NOT UNDER WARRANTY WE FOOTED A $1,200 BIL. THEN WEEKS LATER THE AXLE ON MY 2004 BROKE AS I WAS DRIVING OUT OF MY DRIVEWAY. THAT REPAIR ALSO NOT UNDER WARRANTY COST ANOTHER 1,200 DOLLARS. WE HAVE HAD TO HAVE THE WHEEL BEARINGS REPLACED ALL THE WAY AROUND ON BOTH VEHICLES AND THE ECM REPLACED ON BOTH CARS THIS YEAR. THESE VEHICLES HAVE ALSO EXPERIENCED CONVERTER PROBLEMS AND CONVERTERS WERE REPLACED BY SUBARU ONLY AFTER I KEPT UP A RUNNING BATTLE AND INSISTED THAT THEY WERE UNDER WARRANTY. *TR

I HAVE EXPERIENCED WHAT IS REFERRED TO AS "GHOSTWALKING" IN MY 2005 SUBARU OUTBACK. WHILE DRIVING IN WINTER CONDITIONS SUCH AS SLUSH, SNOW AND ICE MIX, AND BLACK ICE THE CAR FISHTAILS IN THE REAR WHEELS MAKING IT IMPOSSIBLE TO SAFELY DRIVE THIS CAR. HOWEVER DRIVING ON HARDPACK SNOW AND HARDPACK POWDER THE CAR HANDLES FINE. THE CAR FISHTAILS MUCH WORSE WHEN EVEN A LITTLE WEIGHT IS LOADED IN THE REAR. I DO HAVE DEDICATED SNOW TIRES, WITH STUDS. I AM A VERY EXPERIENCED DRIVER IN WINTER CONDITIONS, I DO NOT DRIVE TOO FAST IN POOR ROAD CONDITIONS. THIS IS A SERIOUS PROBLEM THAT APPARENTLY MANY PEOPLE HAVE EXPERIENCED. I HAVE MULTIPLE FRIENDS WHO DRIVE OLDER SUBARU'S WHO HAVE NEVER EXPERIENCED SUCH AN ENCOUNTER WITH THEIR CARS. BOTTOM LINE THIS CAR IS NOT SAFE TO DRIVE ON WINTER ROADS, I HAVE LITERALLY FEARED FOR MY LIFE ON SEVERAL OCCASIONS. PLEASE DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS. *TR

I RESIDE IN THE SIERRA NEVADA MOUNTAINS IN CALIFORNIA AND EXPERIENCE SNOWY/ICY DRIVING CONDITIONS REGULARLY THROUGHOUT THE WINTER. THE OUTBACK WAS PURCHASED FOR ITS PERFORMANCE IN THESE CONDITIONS AND IS EQUIPPED WITH BLIZZAK STUDLESS SNOW TIRES. ON SEVERAL OCCASIONS, IN BOTH CA AND CO, WHILE DRIVING ON PACKED SNOW AT APPROXIMATELY 40 MPH, THE REAR END BEGAN TO FISHTALE OUT OF CONTROL. THIS SITUATION CONTINUED TO WORSEN UNTIL THE SPEED WAS REDUCED TO BELOW 30 MPH. I HAVE SPOKEN TO THE DEALER AND OF COURSE, "THEY HAVE NEVER HEARD OF SUCH AN EVENT" AND DID NOT HAVE ANY IDEA AS TO WHAT MAY HAVE CAUSED THIS CONDITION NOR HOW TO CORRECT. THERE ARE TOO MANY REPORTS OF THIS IDENTICAL OUT OF CONTROL CONDITION FOR IT TO BE COINCIDENTAL, SUBARU NEEDS TO ADDRESS THIS ISSUE BEFORE SOMEONE IS SERIOUSLY INJURED OR KILLED. *TR

I HAVE OWNED AND DRIVEN THIS SUBARU SINCE JULY 06 AND HAVE DRIVEN IT THROUGH 5 NORTHERN ILLINOIS WINTERS. TODAY WAS OUR FIRST SNOWFALL THIS SEASON AND FOR THE FIRST TIME I HAVE NOTICED THAT THE CAR EXHIBITS VERY "UN-NERVING" HANDLING QUALITIES IN VERY LIGHT SNOW ROAD CONDITIONS. SOMETHING HAS CHANGED TO MAKE ME FEEL LIKE I WILL LOOSE CONTROL OF THE VEHICLE. THE CAR FEELS LIKE IT WANTS TO FISHTAIL OUT OF CONTROL AT ANY SPEED OVER 30 MPH. STRANGE "WANDERING" BEST DESCRIBES IT.IT FEELS LIKE I'M DRIVING IN DEEP RUTS OF HEAVY ROAD SNOW THAT WANTS TO PULL THE CAR INTO THE RUTS BUT THE ROAD IS BARELY COVERED. ON TWO LANE ROADS IT FEELS LIKE THE CAR COULD EASILY CROSS THE CENTER LINE BECAUSE OF THIS ODD STEERING FEEDBACK I FEEL ON SLICK SNOW COVERED ROAD CONDITIONS. I DON'T FEEL IT IN RAIN CONDITIONS. IT HAS "NEVER" FELT LIKE THIS BEFORE. THE REAR STRUTS WERE REPLACE LAST SUMMER WITH OEM STRUTS. THE CAR HAS NEVER HAD AN ALIGNMENT BUT HAS ALWAYS TRACKED DOWN THE ROAD VERY STRAIGHT. TIRE WEAR IS EVEN AND TIRES HAVE BEEN ROTATED MULTIPLE TIMES. TIRES ARE BRIDGESTONE TURANZA SERENITY WITH 66K AND BEEN THROUGH 3 WINTERS BEFORE WITH NO HANDLING ISSUE. ONCE I NOTICED ON THIS SITE THAT MANY OUTBACK OWNERS ARE EXPERIENCING THE SAME SYMPTOM, I KNEW I NEEDED TO GET THIS POSTED IN CASE OF AN ACCIDENT. I'M NOW AT LEAST ON RECORD WITH MY "HANDLING CONCERN COMPLAINT" AND SUBARU OF AMERICA CAN'T SAY MY CONCERN WAS NEVER ADDRESSED WITH THE NHTSA. A CAR SHOULD NEVER DISPLAY THE KIND OF HANDLING ISSUES THAT MAKES IT FEEL UNSAFE TO DRIVE IN LIGHT WINTER CONDITIONS. P.S. I TOOK MY SON'S HONDA CRV WITH 198 K FOR A TEST DRIVE IN THE SAME CONDITIONS TODAY,ON THE SAME ROADS AND FOUND ITS HANDLING VERY PREDICTABLE. WHAT IS GOING ON WITH THESE OUTBACKS ? *TR

I AM A VERY EXPERIENCED DRIVER IN SNOWY AND ICY CONDITIONS. MY OUTBACK 2005 2.5I STARTED WIGGLING OUT OF CONTROL (ESPECIALLY FELT THE BACK END WIGGLE LEFT TO RIGHT) ON A STRAIGHT ROAD WITH APPROX 1/2 INCH ICE AND PACKED SNOW CAUSING ME TO SLOW DOWN FROM APPROXIMATELY 40 MPH TO 20 MPH . OTHER 2 WD VEHICLES PASSED US AT MUCH HIGHER SPEEDS WITH NO APPARENT PROBLEM TO KEEP STRAIGHT. OUR CAR HAD 2 ADULTS AND 2 SMALL CHILDREN IN IT WITH SKIING GEAR. CHANGED OUR WINTER TIRES IMMEDIATELY AFTER. THE PROBLEM OCCURRED AGAIN ON A FEW OTHER SIMILAR OCCASIONS, FOR WHICH I WENT TO THE DEALER TO GET ALIGNED, TIRE CHANGED AGAIN. WENT TO DEALER IN 2010 AFTER THIS OCCURRED AGAIN ON THE HIGHWAY WITH ONLY SLUSH AND WATER. I HAD TO SLOW FROM 55 MPH TO 30 MPH TO KEEP CAR IN CONTROL. REMEMBER THIS IS ON THE HIGHWAY!! WENT TO DEALER AGAIN TO RE-ALIGN THE CAR WHICH ACCORDING TO THEM WAS NOT ALIGNED. THE PROBLEM RE-OCCURRED AGAIN THIS WINTER. I AM NOW FED UP, THIS IS A DANGEROUS CAR AND I AM TURNING IT IN TO BUY A NEW CAR. I CAN'T UNDERSTAND WHY SUBARU IS NOT RECALLING TO FIX THE REAR SUSPENSION. *TR

TL* THE CONTACT OWNS A 2005 SUBARU OUTBACK. THE CONTACT STATED THAT THE ACCELERATOR PEDAL WOULD INTERMITTENTLY BECOME UNRESPONSIVE. THE DEALER REPAIRED THE DEFECT, BUT THE FAILURE RECURRED. THE MANUFACTURER WAS NOT CONTACTED. THE VEHICLE WAS NOT REPAIRED. THE FAILURE MILEAGE WAS 65,696 AND THE CURRENT MILEAGE WAS 75,000.

INTERMITTENT THROTTLE DISABLED. CAR BECOMES UNRESPONSIVE TO THE GAS PEDAL. ENGINE CONTINUES TO RUN BUT GAS PEDAL HAS NO RESPONSE. *KB